In this episode of Legal Judg(e)ments, host Bob Stetson sits down with attorney Pat Tinsley to discuss the complexities of federalism and local governance through the lens of a landmark tobacco regulation case in Massachusetts. Pat, who represented the retailers challenging Brookline, MA’s unique tobacco law, shares insights into the statutory interpretation and the ongoing debate over local versus state authority. From the philosophical underpinnings of federalism to the practical implications for businesses and communities, this episode explores how one town’s attempt to phase out tobacco sales has sparked a broader conversation about the limits of local power and the role of the courts in navigating these contentious issues. Download this episode to learn about a case that could shape the future of public health regulations in the Commonwealth and beyond.